-
Editorials
- Bradenton Herald
- Daytona Beach News-Journal
- Florida Times-Union
- Florida Today
- Ft. Myers News-Press
- Gainesville Sun
- Lakeland Ledger
- Miami Herald
- Naples Daily News
- NWF Daily News
- Ocala Star-Banner
- Orlando Sentinel
- Palm Beach Post
- Pensacola News Journal
- Sarasota Herald-Tribune
- TCPalm
- Sun-Sentinel
- Tallahassee Democrat
- Tampa Bay Times
- Columnists
- Cartoons
-
Press Releases
- Sayfie Review
- Jose Oliva
- Nikki Fried
- Bill Galvano
- Ron DeSantis
- Marco Rubio
- Ashley Moody
- Rick Scott
- Jimmy Patronis
- Congressional Delegation ≻
- Matt Gaetz
- Neal Dunn
- Kat Cammack
- Aaron Bean
- John Rutherford
- Michael Waltz
- Cory Mills
- Bill Posey
- Darren Soto
- Maxwell Frost
- Daniel Webster
- Gus Bilirakis
- Anna Paulina Luna
- Kathy Castor
- Laurel Lee
- Vern Buchanan
- Greg Steube
- Scott Franklin
- Byron Donalds
- Sheila Cherfilus McCormick
- Brian Mast
- Lois Frankel
- Jared Moskowitz
- Frederica Wilson
- Debbie Wasserman Schultz
- Mario Diaz-Balart
- Maria Elvira Salazar
- Carlos Gimenez
- Political Links
-
News Links
- Drudge Report
- NewsMax.com
- AP Florida News
- ABC News' The Note
- NBC News' First Read
- Florida Channel
- Florida TV Stations
- Florida Radio Stations
- Capitol Update
- Florida Newspapers
- Florida Trend
- South Florida Business Journal
- Tampa Bay Business Journal
- Orlando Business Journal
- Jacksonville Business Journal
- News Service of Florida
- Politico Playbook
- Washington Post The Daily 202
-
Research
- Florida Fiscal Portal
- Search Florida Laws
- Search House Bills
- Search Senate Bills
- Search County, City Laws
- Search County Clerks' Records
- Cabinet Agendas, Transcripts
- Search Executive Orders
- Search Atty. General Opinions
- Search Supreme Court Docket
- Florida Supreme Court Rulings
- Search Florida Corporations
- Search Administrative Rules
- Proposed Administrative Rules
- View Advertised Contracts
- Refdesk.com
- Government Services Guide
- Electoral Vote Map
-
Reference
- Florida House
- Florida Senate
- Find Your Congressman
- Find Your State Legislator
- Find Your Local Officials
- Find Government Phone #'s
- Florida Agencies
- Florida Cities
- Florida Counties
- Florida Universities
- County Tax Collectors
- County Property Appraisers
- County Clerks of Court
- County Elections Supervisors
- MyFlorida.com
- OPPAGA
- Advertise with us
Herald: Underline is more than a park. It's just what Miami needs | Opinion
Sun-Sentinel: The high cost of playing politics with sheriff's jobs | Editorial
Times: Pinellas County schools' sensible policy on cellphones in classrooms | Editorial
Times: A Swiftie named Jonathan would have something to say about USF's Taylored course | Letters
Herald: Shoot-out doesn't mean Doral is the next South Beach. But it's time to take action | Opinion
Sun-Sentinel: Restoring runoff may loosen extremists' grip | Editorial
Tampa Bay Times: Joe Biden is coming to Tampa today. Here's what you need to know.
Times: Either you think these Florida kids deserve help, or you don't
Florida Supreme Court orders new sentence in juvenile rape case
By JIM SAUNDERS
THE NEWS SERVICE OF FLORIDA
THE CAPITAL, TALLAHASSEE, December 8, 2016.......... In the latest in a series of cases dealing with long prison sentences for juvenile offenders, a divided Florida Supreme Court on Thursday ordered resentencing for a man who at age 15 raped a pregnant woman at knifepoint.
The court, in a 4-3 decision, overturned a 1st District Court of Appeal ruling that upheld a 45-year prison sentence for inmate Thomas Kelsey.
Originally, Kelsey was sentenced in March 2010 in Duval County to two life sentences after being convicted on two counts of sexual battery, armed robbery and armed burglary with an assault or battery. The crimes occurred in 2002.
But a landmark 2010 U.S. Supreme Court decision in a case known as Graham v. Florida, banned life sentences without a "meaningful opportunity" for release for juveniles convicted of non-homicide crimes. That Graham ruling, which came after Kelsey received his life sentences, led to him being resentenced in 2014 to 45 years in prison for each crime, with the sentences running simultaneously.
Kelsey, however, sought another resentencing based on Florida Supreme Court rulings and a 2014 law that revamped sentencing for juveniles.
In Thursday's majority ruling, Justice James E.C. Perry wrote that Kelsey is part of a "narrow class of juvenile offenders" who were resentenced after the Graham decision but before the Legislature revamped the juvenile-sentencing laws in 2014.
"Kelsey argues that his sentence does not currently provide the relief specified in our previous decisions and seeks the judicial review granted to other defendants who, like him, were sentenced to terms that will not provide them a meaningful opportunity for relief in their respective lifetimes. We agree," wrote Perry, who was joined in the majority by Chief Justice Jorge Labarga and justices Barbara Pariente and Peggy Quince.
But in a dissent, Justice Ricky Polston noted that Kelsey was sentenced to 45 years for crimes committed at age 15.
"Because Kelsey's term-of-years aggregate sentence is not a de facto life sentence, Kelsey will have a meaningful opportunity for release during his natural life," wrote Polston, who was joined in the dissent by justices R. Fred Lewis and Charles Canady. "Therefore, Kelsey's aggregate sentence does not violate Graham, and he is not entitled to resentencing."
The U.S. Supreme Court's decisions in the Graham case and in a 2012 case dealing with juveniles convicted of committing murders were based on arguments that life sentences for juveniles violate Eighth Amendment protections against cruel and unusual punishment. The 2014 state law attempted to address the fallout from the U.S. Supreme Court rulings by setting new sentencing guidelines.
Perry wrote that the Florida Supreme Court has determined that the intent of the 2014 law was that "juveniles who are serving lengthy sentences are entitled to periodic judicial reviews to determine whether they can demonstrate maturation and rehabilitation."
He wrote that prosecutors during the resentencing could again seek life in prison for Kelsey, though such a sentence would require periodic judicial reviews of the inmate. But in a concurring opinion, Pariente wrote that she thinks Kelsey would effectively be "precluded from being resentenced to a term exceeding his current 45-year sentence when the sentencing court takes into account all of the sentencing factors set forth" in part of the 2014 law.
Kelsey, who will turn 30 on Saturday, is an inmate at Jefferson Correctional Institution, according to the state Department of Corrections website.